Dietary Supplements: Do They Help?
6 things to know about dietary supplements before taking them
6 things to know about dietary supplements before taking them
Walk down the vitamin and mineral aisle of your local drugstore. You’ll see rows of capsules, liquids and powders listed as dietary supplements. Their labels claim they can help improve your health and well-being. But do they deliver on these promises?
First, you need to know if you need them. Your doctor’s advice is important.
Supplements contain nutrients but they cannot treat or cure disease. Some can be beneficial to your health and for managing some health conditions. But some can put you at risk if you take too many, or if you mix them with medications.
“Not everyone needs supplements. But if you’re thinking of taking them, do your homework,” says Immanuel Hausig, DO, a family medicine physician at Scripps Coastal Medical Center Carlsbad. “Learn how safe and effective they are first.”
Supplements are a $53 billion industry in the United States that continues to grow. There are thousands of dietary supplements available on store shelves ready for purchase without a prescription, which is why you want to be cautious.
With so many choices, it’s important to know how to read product labels and claims before buying. And if you want to read beyond the label, it’s important to know where to get reliable information.
“You can check with your health care provider,” Dr. Hausig says. “Your doctor can tell you what conditions supplements can help with and which ones, if any, are right for you.”
Here are six facts about supplements to consider before taking them:
1. Dietary supplements are not regulated like drugs
The US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) regulates dietary supplements. But it does not regulate them as drugs that can be used to treat or cure a disease. They are regulated as foods.
The FDA does not approve the safety or effectiveness of dietary supplements before they go to market. It leaves that up to the makers of the supplements.
The FDA monitors the safety of supplements once they are on the market. It can remove any supplement product from the market if found not to be safe. It can also take action if the product claims are false or misleading.
2. Dietary supplement makers can make limited health claims
Supplement makers by law cannot claim their product treats or cures a disease or health condition. Only an FDA-approved drug can make such a claim.
However, they can make health claims on how a nutrient or ingredient can help reduce the risk of a disease or health condition. They can claim, for example:
- Getting enough calcium as part of a healthy diet and lifestyle can reduce the risk of osteoporosis.
- Omega-3 fatty acids from fish oils might help some people with heart disease.
There are two types of health claims on labels: qualified and authorized. Authorized claims have been reviewed by the FDA and have significant scientific agreement. Qualified claims have scientific evidence in support but not significant scientific agreement and must be accompanied by a disclaimer.
3. Supplement makers can make claims about effects on body structure and function
In addition to health claims, supplement makers can make structure-function claims. These are claims on how a nutrient or a dietary ingredient affects the structure or function of the human body.
Supplement makers can say, for example:
- Calcium builds strong bones
- Fiber maintains bowel regularity
- Antioxidants maintain cell integrity
4. Supplements can’t replace a healthy, balanced diet
Supplements should not take the place of a healthy, balanced diet. Healthy eating is the best way to get nutrients.
“If you’re thinking of taking a dietary supplement, ask yourself if you can get these nutrients from the foods you’re eating,” Dr. Hausig says. “Most of the time you can. You can even find fortified foods that carry extra nutrients at your grocery store.”
Some people have nutritional deficiencies due to health conditions. Supplements can help fill these gaps.
For example, pregnant women benefit from folic acid supplements, which can lower the risk of certain birth defects. Older adults may find calcium and vitamin D supplements beneficial for bone health.
Dr. Hausig cautions not to take more supplements than you need because of the risk of side effects.
Taking too much vitamin A, for example, can cause headaches and liver damage, reduce bone strength and cause birth defects.
5. Some supplements can interact with medications or affect medical conditions
Before taking supplements, read the label and check with your doctor to see how they might interact with any medication you might be taking and any potential side effects.
Certain supplements may interact with certain medications and reduce their effectiveness. They may also increase the risk of side effects from those medications.
According to the FDA:
- Vitamin K can reduce the ability of a blood thinner to prevent blood from clotting
- St. John’s wort can speed the breakdown of many drugs and reduce their effectiveness
- Antioxidant supplements, like vitamins C and E, might reduce the effectiveness of some types of cancer chemotherapy
6. Use reliable resources to check quality of supplements
In addition to your doctor, you can get reliable information about healthy eating and dietary supplements from some non-commercial sources.
Check the Dietary Guidelines for Americans and MyPlate to learn more about healthy eating.
The US Office of Dietary Supplements provides information about dietary supplements and their ingredients.
The US Pharmacopeia (USP) maintains a dietary supplement verification program. The USP Verified Mark on a dietary supplement indicates that the product meets the following:
- Contains ingredients listed in declared potency and amounts
- Does not contain harmful levels of specified contaminants
- Will break down and release into the body within specified amount of time
- Were made according to Good Manufacturing Practices for dietary supplements.
“It’s essential to approach dietary supplements with a balanced perspective, understanding their benefits and limitations,” Dr. Hausig says. “Your doctor can guide you based on your individual health needs.”